2021 Page One Award Categories

1. NEWSPAPER/NEWS WRITING

aBreaking News Coverage (Up to three stories showing excellence in coverage of a single news event that’s breaking/was not expected. Examples include but aren’t limited to crime stories, public safety emergencies, deaths/resignations involving prominent news figures and sudden layoffs/shutdowns. The goal is to showcase depth of coverage from a journalist or journalists working on a tight deadline on news that was not expected. Entries should be focused on first day coverage and quick follow-ups. Note: Coverage related to the George Floyd killing likely would fall under Breaking News rather than Deadline News)

b. Deadline News Coverage (Up to three stories showing excellence in coverage of a single news event where journalists could plan for the event without knowing the news. Examples include but aren’t limited to election results, court cases, study/data releases and debates at the Legislature, city/county council or school board. The goal is to showcase coverage from a journalist or journalists that’s distinguished by smart context and/or unique explanatory approaches while fairly representing a variety of perspectives. Entries should be focused on first day coverage and quick follow-ups. Note: Coverage related to COVID-19 likely would fall under Deadline News rather than Breaking News)

c. Feature Writing (Up to three stories showing one feature writer’s ability to command attention through profiles or trend pieces with unique characters, rich scenes and/or unexpected angles.)

d. Enterprise/In-Depth Story (One story that reflects a journalist’s or team of journalists’ ingenuity, use of sources and/or special research to dig deeper and/or capture more complexity than a typical news story.)

e. Enterprise/In-Depth Series (Up to three stories that reflect a journalist’s or team of journalists’ ingenuity, use of sources and/or special research to dig deeper and/or capture more complexity than a typical news story.)

f. Investigative (Up to three stories on a single topic or news event containing information not readily available to the news media or public and obtained through reporter initiative)

g. Business News Coverage (Up to three distinct stories, or a series of up to three stories, that’s focused on business-related news)

h. Sports News Coverage (Up to three distinct stories, or a series of up to three stories, on sports-related news)

i. Sports Feature Writing (Up to three stories showing one feature writer’s ability to command attention to subjects in professional and amateur sports through profiles or trend pieces with unique characters, rich scenes and/or unexpected angles)

j. Sports Columns (Up to three columns by one writer whose work regularly appears in the sports section)

k. Arts & Entertainment Coverage (Up to three distinct stories, or a series of up to three stories focusing on arts & entertainment-related news)

l. Arts Criticism/Reviews (Up to three stories that illustrate a journalist’s competence in criticizing or reviewing performance, musical groups, restaurants or other similar entities/events)

m. Columns (Up to three columns by one writer written for any section, but not the op-ed page)

n. Editorials and Commentary (Up to three single editorials and/or commentary pieces or columns published on the op-ed page)

o. Graphics/Art and illustration (Up to three examples of original artwork, graphs, diagrams, maps or other visual elements that illustrate a story)

p. Page Design (A single page design: taking into account layout and page composition, use of headlines, art, graphics etc.)

q. Headlines (A collection of up to three headlines, submitted along with the accompanying stories)

r. Best issue (Based on reporting, writing, photography, graphics/illustration, layout, copy-handling, etc.)

2. MAGAZINE

a. Best Profile Story (A single profile story)

b. Best Feature Story (A single feature story)

c. Best Department (A magazine component appearing under the same heading and possibly, but not always, written by different writers); send 3 unique examples

d. Best Column (A magazine component appearing under the same heading and always written by the same author); send 3 unique examples

e. Best Cover (A single magazine cover)

f. Best Page Design (A full story or feature layout, single page, two-page or double-truck design)

g. Graphics/Art and illustration (Up to three examples of original artwork, graphs, diagrams, maps or other visual elements that illustrate a story)

h. Best issue (Based on writing, photography, graphics/illustration, layout)

3. TELEVISION

a. Spot/Breaking news (coverage of an unscheduled event broadcast within 24 hours; may be a single story or compilation of coverage on a single event)

b. Hard News report (best coverage of a news-related topic; may include in-depth, planned coverage of a single event, or enterprise reporting)

c. Feature (single story done for some other factor than timeliness – may include profile, human interest, or trend stories)

d. Special Project/In-Depth series (a single report or series of reports going in-depth on a particular subject, helping the viewer understand a situation beyond information in a typical news story)

e. Investigative (One or more stories containing information not readily available to the news media or public and obtained through reporter initiative)

f. Newscast (One regularly-scheduled newscast airing on any day in the contest year. The entry should represent the station’s best work in news content, execution, and overall presentation)

g.  Sports News Coverage (Up to three distinct stories, or a series of up to three stories, that’s focused on sports-related news.) 

4. RADIO

a. Spot/Breaking news (coverage of an unscheduled event broadcast within 24 hours; may be a single story or compilation of coverage on a single event)

b. Hard News report (best coverage of a news-related topic; may include in-depth, planned coverage of a single event, or enterprise reporting)

c. Feature (single story done for some other factor than timeliness–may include profile, human interest, or trend stories)

d. Special Project/In-Depth series (a single report or series of reports going in-depth on a particular subject, helping the viewer understand a situation beyond information in a typical news story)

e. Investigative (One or more stories containing information not readily available to the news media or public and obtained through reporter initiative)

f. Newscast (One regularly-scheduled newscast airing on any day in the contest year. The entry should represent the station’s best work in news content, execution, and overall presentation)

g. Sports News Coverage (Up to three distinct stories, or a series of up to three stories, that’s focused on sports-related news)

5. ONLINE

a. Best Website (Best use of a website for providing news to an online audience. Judges will look at areas such as ease of navigation, creative design concepts, good organization and degree to which online resources enhance reporting.)

b. Best single news story (Best online coverage of a single news story or event)

c. Best continuing coverage (Two or more online reports demonstrating ongoing coverage of a news event; including original or web-only content)

d. Best single feature story/package (Best online presentation of a single feature story, with emphasis on how online attributes enhance storytelling. Arts & Entertainment coverage is eligible) 

e. Best single sports story/package (Best online presentation of a single sports story, with emphasis on how online attributes enhance storytelling) 

f. Best use of multimedia (Demonstrates outstanding use of photos, galleries, video and/or audio to enhance original story)

g. Best social media account – Individual (For a social media account on any platform run by one journalist that best demonstrates an understanding of audience, an appreciation for the strengths and weaknesses of the platform, while showing a commitment to innovation and an adherence to SPJ’s Code of Ethics)

h. Best social media account – Institutional (For a social media account run by multiple journalists that best demonstrates an understanding of audience, an appreciation for the strengths and weaknesses of the platform, while showing a commitment to innovation and an adherence to SPJ’s Code of Ethics)

i. Best news video (Single video, or series of videos on the same subject, produced to appear online-only)

j. Best newsroom blog (submit URL for blog, judged on overall excellence in news coverage, affiliated with a newspaper, magazine, TV or radio station)

k. Best independent news blog (submit URL for blog, judged on overall excellence in news coverage, not affiliated with a newspaper, magazine, TV or radio station)

l. Best infographic/data visualization (Outstanding data presentation that showcases unique online capabilities) 

6. PHOTOGRAPHY

The collection of photos must come from the same photographer.

a. Best News Photography (Best use of photography in news stories. Submit a collection of up to three (3) news photos from the same photographer.)

b. Best Feature Photography (Best use of photography in feature stories. Submit a collection of up to three (3) feature photos from the same photographer.)

c. Best Portrait Photography (Best use of portrait photography. Submit a collection of up to three (3) portrait photos from the same photographer.)

d. Best Sports Photography (Best use of photography in sports stories. Submit a collection of up to three (3) sports photos from the same photographer.)

7. SPECIAL AWARDS

a. Young Journalist of the Year (Award given to outstanding journalist in any medium with less than 10 years experience; submit three examples of work and letter of nomination)

b. Journalist of the Year (Award given to outstanding journalist in any medium with 10 or more years of experience; submit three examples of work and letter of nomination)

c. Story of the Year (Award for general excellence in any medium, covering a single story or news event submit up to three examples of work and letter of nomination)

d. Best Use of Public Records (Award for excellence in any medium covering a story or news event where use of public records played a role in getting and telling the story; submit up three examples of work and a narrative letter explaining work and its use of public records)

e. Best Beat Reporting (Award recognizing an enterprising reporter in any medium who follows a single subject or topic throughout the year. Entries should include three examples of reporting and a narrative letter explaining any other relevant facts a judge may use to determine the state’s top beat reporter.)

f. Freedom of Information Award (This award recognizes efforts by news organizations to further the cause of First Amendment freedoms and freedom of information. Entries can includes news stories, columns, editorials and other public advocacy actions, including requests for advisory opinions and court cases. Each news organization may submit one entry that includes up to five examples that highlight the effort.)

Entry Tiers

  • Newspaper/News Writing [50,000+ circulation; stories only published online, such as in an online-only publication, are eligible to compete in this category]
  • Newspaper [LESS than 50,000 circulation]
  • Magazine
  • Television [50+ newsroom employees]
  • Television [Fewer than 50 newsroom employees]
  • For television and newspaper, contestants may enter tiers higher than their circulation/employee class, but not lower. If you enter a higher tier, you may not enter your own tier.
  • Radio
  • Online
  • Photography [All photo entries will be judged against each other regardless of publication size]

CLICK HERE to access the contest submission form

Apply for a scholarship to SPJ’s national journalism conference Sept. 12-13

Minnesota SPJ is providing a limited number of scholarships to cover entry fees for journalists in the state who are interested in attending the 2020 SPJ Conference.

The online event is scheduled for Sept. 12-13. Speakers include Marty Baron of The Washington Post, Nikole Hannah-Jones of The New York Times Magazine and Jorge Ramos from Univision.

Scholarship applications are due at midnight on Monday, Aug. 31.  Preference will be given to SPJ members. We will consider applications from student journalists, as well.

Go here to learn more about the event. Go here to apply for a scholarship.

MNSPJ responds to protest outside WCCO reporter’s home

Video has surfaced of a protest outside of WCCO reporter Liz Collin’s home, where a pinata replica of her was destroyed by protesters. The Minnesota Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists supports the public’s constitutional right to protest peacefully, but views the destruction of Collin’s image on her private property to be a direct threat against her as a journalist.

In this current climate, journalists have been regularly disparaged and threatened while doing their jobs, and many have dealt with the abuse quietly while they proceed with their important work. We encourage the general public to use respectful and peaceful means to communicate dissatisfaction with journalists’ coverage, such as contacting them or their supervisors directly or demonstrating outside of their place of work, rather than using threats and intimidation to attack them personally.

We also urge media outlets to address concerns about conflicts of interest in a timely and transparent manner. At this moment in particular, it is essential that the industry do its part to maintain the public’s trust.

MNSPJ opposes change to Mpls. Police PIO role

Last night, the MNSPJ board emailed Minneapolis City Council members to speak out against a proposed change to the Minneapolis Police Public Information Officer position:

Dear Council Member,

We’re writing to you today, as the board of the Minnesota Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, to express our concerns about a proposal regarding the Minneapolis Police Department’s Public Information Officer (PIO).

Our understanding is that, should the council approve this budget amendment, the PIO position would be eliminated and the city’s communications team would take over police communications. We strongly discourage this change, and request that members of the City Council table Friday’s vote until journalists and members of the public have an opportunity to weigh in.

Our primary concern is that the city’s communications department is not suited to this role. An effective PIO must have the trust both of police officers and journalists, and that takes time – 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Will a communications liaison be on the scene of late-night shootings? Will he or she give press conferences and return phone calls on weekends and city holidays?

We are also concerned that repositioning police communications will take away the autonomy that the PIO role allows. Public safety information should never be vulnerable to manipulation based on city politics and sentiments.

There is a precedent for this: In 2003, SPJ responded when then-Mayor RT Rybak wanted to eliminate the MPD PIO. The board’s primary goal then, as now, was to ensure transparency around taxpayer-funded public safety and law enforcement.

We fully recognize and understand the communication issues that exist within the current PIO model, but do not believe that eliminating that channel of communication will solve the problem. At a time when there is a renewed call for police transparency, any action to remove the PIO and undermine the position by placing it under city direction would further erode public trust.

Thank you for your time. If you have any questions or would like to discuss this issue further, please feel free to contact our president, Emma Nelson.

Sincerely,
The Board of the Minnesota Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists

Meet candidates for the 2020-21 MNSPJ Board

SPJ members in good standing should watch for an email on Monday, June 22, with your ballot to elect the 2020-21 board of directors at MNSPJ. Voting will end on Monday, July 20, with winners announced at the MNSPJ annual meeting.
Here are the candidates for three officer positions: president-elect; secretary; and treasurer. Emma Nelson, who was elected president-elect in 2019, will become president next month. Each of the newly elected officers will serve a one-year term; the new president-elect will serve as president from July 2021 to June 2022. There are four open seats for directors, each with two-year terms.

 

President-elect
Christopher Snowbeck
Bio: I’ve been a health care reporter since 1994, working at newspapers in Indiana, Virginia and Pennsylvania before returning to Minnesota in 2006. I worked at the Pioneer Press for eight years before being hired by the Star Tribune in 2014. Currently, I’m on the Star Tribune’s business desk, covering the business of health care. I’ve been a board member at MNSPJ since 2014.
Candidate Statement: It’s never been more important to explain and celebrate the work of journalists in Minnesota.  I’d like to return to the board to keep working on two key projects that were under way when COVID-19 disrupted life in Minnesota.  The board had just launched a great program called The Inside Scoop where reporters and editors visit high school classes to explain the work we do as journalists while teaching civic reasoning skills.  We need to continue and expand that work.  And then, after working to strengthen the Page One Awards contest in 2018-19, we were hoping to re-invent the Page One Awards banquet this spring.  I have great hopes for next year’s banquet, whether it be virtual or in-person.  There’s more work to be done on our technology platform for running the Page One Awards.  I have ideas for recruiting members to MNSPJ.  And I’d like to help the chapter do a better job communicating with journalists across the state.
 
Secretary
Taryn Phaneuf
Bio: Taryn Phaneuf is a digital journalist who cares about explaining what’s going on behind issues and trends, especially those that impact a person’s quality of life. She works as a data reporter and researcher at the Minneapolis/St. Paul Business Journal and teaches at the University of Minnesota journalism school. She previously worked as an independent journalist covering food and agriculture, education, public health and other topics. Her work appears in MinnPostCrosscutThe AtlanticCivil Eats and The Inlander, among others. In addition to teaching an introductory course in news writing and reporting at the University of Minnesota, she returns each year as a writing coach to Mountain Workshops, a visual journalism bootcamp by Western Kentucky University.
Candidate Statement: I was lucky to have the opportunity to join the MNSPJ Board in the fall. Since then, I’ve seen the ways this organization advocates for free speech and a free press, educates the public and supports young journalists. I’m eager to be more involved in the coming year, which is why I’m asking for your vote to become a board officer and serve as secretary.  In that role, I will work to keep the board organized and accountable to MNSPJ’s mission and to bring fresh ideas and energy as we respond to important issues facing our industry.
 
Treasurer
Briana Bierschbach
Bio: My name is Briana Bierschbach and I’m running to be the treasurer of the Minnesota Society of Professional Journalists. I’m a state government reporter at the Star Tribune who has spent a decade covering politics, starting part-time at the Minnesota Capitol for the Associated Press right out of college. I’ve also worked for MinnPost and MPR News. 
Candidate Statement: I’ve been a member of the SPJ since 2018 and took over as treasurer shortly after joining the board. Since then, I’ve helped keep track of our books, deliver financial reports to our national chapter and get checks to everyone from our scholarship recipients to our vendors who work with us to put on events in the community. I’m running for a second term as treasurer because I want to continue to be a part of the work SPJ does to help journalists succeed financially, particularly as many face setbacks like layoffs and limited freelance work during the coronavirus pandemic.  
 
Board Members (four open seats)
 
Brian Arola
Bio: I joined The Free Press in Mankato as a health and nonprofits reporter in 2016. While health remains my primary beat, my other coverage areas range from homelessness to city councils to refugee resettlement. Originally from the Iron Range in northern Minnesota, I started my journalism career at the Hibbing Daily Tribune after graduating from the University of Minnesota.
Candidate statement: As an outstate reporter, I’d be honored to bring a new voice to the Minnesota Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, an organization which so aligns with my values. The board’s work advocating for journalists is always important, but especially so now when attacks on the free press are so frequent and so many news organizations are struggling.  Working in Mankato and Hibbing solidified my passion for local news and the vital role journalists play in informing our communities. Running for a position on the board of directors is an opportunity to turn that passion into service. By promoting news media literacy, empowering future generations of journalists and highlighting the great work of my fellow journalists, I hope to carry on SPJ’s critical mission. 
 
Katie Galioto
Biography: I’m a reporter for the Star Tribune based in the paper’s Duluth bureau, where I cover local governments, schools and a little bit of everything else. I was born and raised in the suburbs of Minneapolis and attended college at the University of Notre Dame, where I caught the journalism bug. After graduating in 2018, I had intern stints at the Chicago Tribune and Politico before returning to Minnesota to start exploring and telling the stories in the Northland.
Statement: Journalists in Minnesota today are doing crucial, historic work while simultaneously facing unprecedented challenges — financial difficulties, physical threats, a need for more rigorous fact-checking to hold those in power accountable and outreach to earn the trust of communities that feel overlooked. I want to join the SPJ board because I believe the work this network produces is vital to this state. I’ve looked to SPJ for wisdom and resources multiple times in my young career, and I’d like to amplify the society’s mission in the Duluth region, particularly for aspiring journalists in northern Minnesota.
 
Nate Gotlieb
Bio: Nate is a journalist at the Southwest Journal community newspaper in Minneapolis, where he covers schools, development, environmental topics and community news. Previously, he was a reporter at the Mankato Free Press, an intern at the St. Cloud Times and part of the digital team at Fox Sports North. He is a graduate of the University of Minnesota School of Journalism and Mass Communication, where he wrote for the Minnesota Daily’s sports department.
Candidate Statement: Nate is running for the SPJ board because he’s passionate about local news and maintaining a free and vigorous press. He appreciates the impact journalism can have on a community and the news organizations in the Twin Cities doing such critical work. Nate is also passionate about digital journalism, learning new tools and helping future generations of journalists. He hopes to help foster and maintain connections between journalists during a time of physical distancing if elected to the board. 
 
Fred Melo
Bio: A Boston boy who lost his way and landed far from home, Frederick Melo has been a reporter with the St. Paul Pioneer Press since January 2005. He resides in a 1916 St. Paul home with his St. Paul-reared wife and their two St. Paul children.
Candidate Statement: It’s been an honor to serve on the board of MNSPJ these past four years, including spending the last three years as a board officer (Secretary). It’s a small little torch and it’s time to pass it. I’m asking for your vote to re-elect me to the board. For Secretary, I wholeheartedly nominate and endorse Taryn Phaneuf, who will do an excellent job as Secretary. 
I’ve worked hard on efforts to connect younger folks to MNSPJ, to jobs, to scholarships, to our national conference and to the good work that journalists do. For three years I have co-chaired our scholarship committee, which awarded $3,500 in funds to college students this year. I recently spoke to the college SPJ chapter and co-chaired a public zoom discussion with them on diversity in the media. For four years, I’ve overseen Intern Night at WCCO, a networking event that draws a wide range of media employers for a panel discussion with college students each October. I’m not sure how we will pull it off this year, but I promise to find a way! 
For the past two years, I’ve organized autumn Media Mixers at St. Paul taprooms. How will we pull that off this year? Two words: No idea! Give me a minute to think about it, and please give me your vote!
 
Nina Moini
Bio/Candidate Statement: Thank you for considering me for this opportunity to represent and advocate for Minnesota journalists. I have been reporting in Minnesota for the past seven years for WCCO-TV and most recently, MPR News. Before that, I was a multi-media journalist for WBBH/WZVN-TV in Southwest Florida for two years. I am also a proud graduate of the Missouri School of Journalism and fully realize I may lose some votes for sharing that!  I got my first shot as a reporter at 16 years old through a magazine show for teens on KARE 11 called The Whatever Show. I am proud that our state’s exceptional professional journalists really helped raise me. With that foundation, I was able to go on to report on a wide range of stories and fortunate to catch a few awards along the way. It is important to celebrate our hard work and service to the public, but also important to facilitate a community for journalists to be heard and supported. I believe community is especially needed in these times of (more than usual) under-staffing, attacks on journalists/news organizations, and financial problems.
As an Iranian-American immigrant kid growing up in Apple Valley, I gravitated toward journalism because I truly believe we are all more alike than different. I believe the best storytelling captures our deepest commonalities. I aim to help Minnesotans talk across differences and enrich their own lives. I am also passionate about making this industry one that is accessible to young reporters who come from all backgrounds and especially those who may not have the family means to make it in this business early on. I would be honored to help us advocate for ourselves and the future of our industry.
 
Tyler Newman
Bio: I’ve worked with print and digital newsrooms in Saint Paul, Minneapolis, and Seattle. Publications include: the Associated Press, the Growler, Leafly, and Public Radio International. 
Candidate Statement: Most of my contributions to journalism have been done on a freelance basis. For some, this is a way of gathering clips, but for me it was a way to train flexibility about where I contributed my work, as well as a way to retain control over what I wrote about. 
Freelance journalism is on the rise. Practitioners of our craft are turning to it for a number of reasons. As a member of the SPJ’s national freelance committee, I’ve worked with fellow freelancers across the country, learned more about their unique achievements and struggles, and tried to address them with the committee. 
As a member of the Minnesota SPJ pro chapter, I would use this accumulated experience, and the input of members of SPJ in Minnesota, to fight for freelancers in my own state. Access to press credentials, protection under shield laws and other legal protections for journalists, and equitable contracts — are all matters that I would like to address with the talented journalists of our Minnesota board. 
Journalism must adapt to the changing world around it. Accommodating the industry for it’s growing ranks of freelancers, echoing a broader trend in the U.S. labor market, is a pillar of that transformation. 
While it’s not the only reform that must come to our field, it’s the one I have the most experience with. For the rest that must come, I rely on the experience of my fellow board members, journalists around the state, and the public, so that the free press remains an effective institution in the digital age. 
  

Journalists Celebrate Page One Awards with first virtual Ceremony

More than 100 people tuned in Tuesday for the first-ever virtual ceremony to recognize winners of the Page One Awards, the annual journalism contest sponsored by the Minnesota Society of Professional Journalists (MNSPJ).

 

You can watch a replay of the event at MNSPJ’s YouTube page.

 

Marianne Combs of MPR News earned recognition as Journalist of the Year for reporting on sexual abuse at the Children’s Theater Company.  Story of the Year went to KARE 11 for an investigation into prosecutions hobbled by untested rape kits.  Journalists at the Star Tribune were honored with Best Use of Public Records for detailing how families struggle to obtain benefits for children with complex medical needs.

 

Health concerns with the COVID-19 pandemic prompted MNSPJ to honor journalists during an online ceremony, in lieu of the the annual Page One Awards banquet. Tane Danger, co-founder of the The Theater of Public Policy, hosted the event, which featured comments from keynote speaker Samara Freemark, co-creator and senior producer of AMP Reports’ investigative podcast “In the Dark.” 

 

Before and during Tuesday’s event, donors contributed more than $1,300 to a fund that will help journalists impacted by the economic turmoil with COVID-19.  MNSPJ is contributing $500 to the fund, as well.  Those in need are encouraged to apply for a small grant.

 

Attorney Leita Walker received the Peter S. Popovich Award, which is presented annually by the MNSPJ board to the person or organization that exemplifies the fight for First Amendment rights. In her video acceptance, Walker wore a Superman shirt in honor of John Borger, a pre-eminent First Amendment attorney who passed away late last year.

 

MNSPJ also presented Pioneer Press columnist Ruben Rosario with a lifetime achievement award. Rosario announced earlier this year his retirement plans after decades of work in the Twin Cities and New York.

 

Page One Award winners have been posted to the MNSPJ website with finalists grouped across nine divisions: large newspapers; small newspapers; magazines; large television newsrooms; small television newsrooms; radio; online; photography; and special awards

 

MNSPJ will make arrangements this summer for distribution of plaques and certificates.  The contest was judged by journalists coordinated by the Society of Professional Journalists – Colorado Professional chapter.